Trade Union Access Requests: What nursery employers need to know
Many nursery providers have recently reported receiving trade union access requests from the National Education Union (NEU). These requests stem from the new rights introduced under the Employment Rights Act 2025, and understandably, many employers are unsure about what they mean and how they should respond.
Here’s what you need to know.
Key points for nursery employers
- Trade unions can request access to workplaces under the Employment Rights Act 2025.
- Most nursery employers cannot reject requests outright.
- Employers can negotiate practical arrangements to protect safeguarding and operations.
- Disputes can be referred to the Central Arbitration Committee (CAC).
What is a Trade Union Access Request?
Under the Employment Rights Act 2025, independent trade unions can request access to workplaces to:
- Meet with workers
- Recruit members
- Organise and engage with employees
The legislation gives qualifying trade unions the right to seek access to workers, subject to practical considerations and appropriate workplace safeguards.
Can nursery employers refuse a trade union access request?
In most cases, employers will not be able to completely reject a trade union access request. However, employers can set out how an access request might “unreasonably interfere” with their business – this has to be set out in the employer’s response.
The legislation creates a presumption that qualifying trade unions should be able to access workers, subject to practical safeguards and reasonable business considerations.
When can the request be rejected?
There are only limited circumstances where an employer may be able to reject a request.
1. Small employers
Employers with fewer than 21 staff are outside the scope of a request. It is important to note that this threshold applies across the nursery and the group. A setting with fewer than 21 employees may still be covered if the wider organisation employs more than 21 staff.
2. Domestic residence
Where childcare is provided from a domestic residence, providers may reject requests for physical entry.
However, employers may still be expected to facilitate digital access to employees.
3. Existing union arrangements
A request may be rejected where:
- Another trade union is already formally recognised in the workplace, or
- Workers are already covered by an existing statutory access agreement.
When can a request be partially rejected or negotiated?
There may be valid reasons to challenge aspects of a request, even where access itself cannot be refused.
Unreasonable disruption to operations
Employers can explain why certain times would not be practical for meetings, such as:
- Child drop-off and collection periods
- Meal times and nap times requiring extra supervision
- Staff handovers
- Regulatory inspections
- Other operationally critical periods
Insufficient notice
A short notice period, such as one week, may not be sufficient to make suitable arrangements, particularly where a designated contact within the organisation is needed to manage the process.
Safeguarding considerations
Safeguarding must remain a priority. Employers may object to access arrangements that could interfere with:
- Supervision requirements
- Staffing ratios
- Visits during rest periods
Lack of suitable space
Some settings do not have private meeting spaces available during operational hours. This may justify negotiating alternative arrangements.
Data protection concerns
The access regime does not override data protection law.
Employers should not feel obliged to provide personal employee data, or provide access to a nursery management platform, simply because access has been requested. Alternative solutions may be available, such as sharing union information through an internal communication platform and facilitating communication without disclosing employee contact details.
What happens if there is a disagreement?
Where concerns are raised, the legislation provides for a 25-working-day negotiation period between the employer and the trade union.
The purpose of this period is to identify a practical solution that balances the union’s statutory rights with the operational needs of the employer.
If agreement cannot be reached, the matter can be referred to the Central Arbitration Committee (CAC), which can make a binding determination on the terms of access.
What are NDNA doing?
NDNA is seeking further advice and guidance to support employers through this process. We will also be raising the approach of unions at a national level with their representatives and the Government to ensure:
- Requests are made and managed lawfully
- The realities of operating childcare settings are recognised
- The impact on providers, children and working families is properly considered.
We will continue to monitor developments, gather evidence and keep the sector informed.
What should providers do if they receive a request?
If you receive a trade union access request, do not ignore it.
Instead:
- Check any statutory deadlines immediately
- Consider whether any practical concerns need to be raised
- Seek to negotiate arrangements that protect safeguarding, confidentiality and staffing ratios while enabling lawful access
- Seek professional advice where necessary.
Further information
For additional guidance, visit:
Similar Articles
Top tips: Motivating staff
Early years activity: Create a healthy eating rhyme